OrderShield
Executive Summary
Vision Statement
Empower e-commerce sellers to focus on their craft, not disputes, through automated protection and intelligent case management
Problem Summary
E-commerce sellers face significant challenges managing package delivery disputes, particularly when tracking information is ambiguous or customers are uncooperative. These disputes often lead to financial losses, wasted time, and damaged seller ratings. Common pain points include:
- Inconsistent tracking data interpretation
- Unresponsive buyers during investigations
- Manual evidence collection for cases
- Limited integration with carrier systems
- Pressure to resolve disputes quickly to maintain platform ratings
Proposed Solution
OrderShield is an integrated platform that automatically analyzes tracking data, generates evidence reports, and provides structured workflows for managing delivery disputes. Key features include:
- Carrier-agnostic tracking analysis: Cross-references multiple tracking points to identify delivery patterns
- Automated evidence packets: Compiles screenshots, tracking logs, and delivery confirmation data
- Case management dashboard: Tracks dispute progress and suggests next steps
- Pre-built response templates: For common scenarios like non-delivery claims
- Integration with Etsy's case system
Market Analysis
Target Audience
Target Audience Profile
Primary Users
- Etsy sellers with $500+/month revenue
- Shopify/Big Cartel store owners handling frequent shipments
- E-commerce teams managing multiple platforms
Key Characteristics
- Experience 5+ delivery disputes/month
- Value platform ratings (Star Seller status, eBay ratings)
- Seek to reduce time spent on customer service
- Willing to pay for tools that protect their revenue
Niche Validation
The source post demonstrates strong validation:
- High engagement: 342 upvotes (0.98 ratio) and 73 comments
- Clear pain points: Multiple commenters suggest filing USPS claims and handling disputes through Etsy's system
- Market size: Etsy alone has 7.5M active sellers (Q1 2023), with similar needs across other platforms
Google Trends Keywords
Market Size Estimation
Serviceable Available Market (SAM) Etsy sellers: 7.5M Shopify merchants: 4.6M Targeting 10% adoption: 1.2M users
Serviceable Obtainable Market (SOM) Year 1 target: 50,000 users (4.2% of SAM) Year 3 target: 200,000 users
Total Addressable Market (TAM) Global e-commerce market: $5.4T (2023) Dispute-prone sellers subset: ~20% = $1.08T
Competitive Landscape
Existing solutions focus on individual platform tools:
- Etsy's case system: Limited tracking integration
- Carrier apps: USPS, FedEx tools for tracking but no dispute workflows
- Third-party dispute tools: Primarily for eBay, not Etsy Gap: No unified platform combining tracking analysis, evidence collection, and case management
Product Requirements
User Stories
As a seller, I want to automatically analyze tracking data to determine delivery status before responding to buyers
MVP Feature Set
Multi-carrier tracking integration
Automated evidence packet generation
Basic case management dashboard
Non-Functional Requirements
Real-time tracking updates
Etsy API integration for case submissions
Audit logs for dispute history
Key Performance Indicators
Dispute resolution time reduction
User retention rate
Case win rate
Data Visualizations
Visual Analysis Summary
Dispute resolution time comparison before/after using OrderShield
Loading Chart...
Go-to-Market Strategy
Core Marketing Message
Protect your revenue and ratings with automated dispute resolution. Get back to selling while we handle the paperwork
Initial Launch Channels
- Targeted Reddit communities: r/EtsySellers, r/Shopify
- Etsy Seller Conferences: Sponsor events focused on seller success
- Micro-influencer partnerships: Collaborate with Etsy seller educators
Strategic Metrics
Problem Urgency
High
Solution Complexity
Medium
Defensibility Moat
Network effects from carrier API integrations Proprietary tracking pattern analysis algorithms High switching costs due to case history
Source Post Metrics
Business Strategy
Monetization Strategy
Freemium model:
- Basic: $9/mo - Dispute tracking, basic templates
- Pro: $29/mo - Advanced tracking analysis, automated evidence packets
- Enterprise: Custom pricing - API access, team accounts
Financial Projections
Year 1: $450,000 (50k users @ $9 avg) Year 3: $2.9M (100k users @ $29 avg) Gross margins: 80-90% (SaaS model)
Tech Stack
Node.js with NestJS framework for scalable API development
PostgreSQL for relational data (cases, users) + Redis for real-time tracking updates
Next.js for server-side rendering and SEO optimization
Carrier APIs (USPS, FedEx, DHL), Etsy API integration, Stripe for payments
Risk Assessment
Identified Risks
- Carrier API reliability: Some carriers have inconsistent tracking data
- Etsy policy changes: Platform may modify dispute resolution processes
Mitigation Strategy
- Build fallback tracking analysis using web scraping
- Maintain close partnership with Etsy through developer program